Homily for the 20th Sunday in Ordinary Time Year A 2014
Isa 56:1, 6-7 • Rom 11:13-15, 29-32 • Matthew 15:21-28
Introduction
A story is told of Protestant man who was
the only non-Catholic in a certain town.
When he died, of course he could not be buried in a Catholic cemetery;
that is how things were done in those days.
Out of consideration, however, the Catholic pastor allowed him to be
buried right outside the fence of the Catholic cemetery.
A few years later, the daughter of this man
returned home and of course she went to put some flowers to her dad’s grave,
whose location outside the fence she remembered very well. To her great dismay, she could not find the
grave.
Very angry, she stormed into the rectory
office and gave the pastor a her piece of mind.
“Not only did you refuse to bury my father in the cemetery,” she told
him, “but even in death you dishonour him by destroying his grave?” She went on and on, for quite a while, about
all that is wrong with the Catholic Church.
Finally when she was done, the priest told
her: “We did not move the grave of your father; we moved the fence of the
cemetery, to include your father’s grave.”
Scripture and Theology
The question of inclusion and exclusion has
always been a thorny one for Christians and even before that of our Jewish
ancestors.
Today’s first reading from Isaiah wrestles
with this problem. This passage is set
after the exile of the Jewish people, when the inter-mingling of the Jews and
the foreigners was increasing. And so the
Jews were asking themselves: does God really accept the sacrifices and prayers
of these foreigners?
Isaiah answers these questions, first by
laying down the minimum conditions which foreigners who wish to serve in the
temple must fulfil.
·
They must observe the Sabbath
·
They must obey the commandments
of the Covenant that applied to them.
If they kept these conditions, they would
be proving that they have faith in God. And
having faith in God is the basic criterion for inclusion among the people God calls
his own, whether one is Jewish or not.
And that is why at the end of the reading God says: “My house shall be
called a house of prayer for all peoples.”
In the gospel Jesus deals with the same
problem. Here is Jesus, a Jewish Rabbi,
who is trying to reform his society so that they could be more faithful to
God. Should he give this message and
work his miracles among non Jews as well?
For the woman in the gospel was a Canaanite, one of the many pagan
neighbours of the Jews. Should he help
her and cure her daughter?
The dialogue in the gospel story, at first
sight, might suggest that Jesus does not want to share the Good News with non-Jews. “I was sent only to the lost sheep of the
house of Israel,” he says. But clearly
from reading the whole of the gospels and even from this passage itself, we
know that the issue is more complicated.
For Jesus say these things to give the woman a chance to argue her case. And indeed the woman is up to the challenge.
The Canaanite woman makes the perfect
argument for sharing God’s blessings with the non-Jewish people as well. She tells Jesus that the left-overs are good
enough for the dogs, meaning that Jesus must have something left over in his
work even for the non-Jews. But most
important of all, she fulfils the essential condition that Isaiah had indicated
earlier: the foreigners must be people of faith. This recognizes Jesus as Lord and sees in him
the power of God. That is why Jesus says
to her: “O woman, great is your faith.
Let it be done for you as you wish.”
And the woman’s daughter was healed from that hour.
Christian Life
We today also wrestle with this question of
whether those outside the Church can receive God’s blessings. People often ask questions like:
·
Can non-Catholics receive
communion and other sacraments?
·
Should the Catholic Church be
involved in ecumenical and inter-religious dialogue and activities with other
Christians and even non-Christians?
·
Will the Jews, Muslims and those
we call heathens go to heaven?
Now if I tried to reflect on all these issues
in my homily, we would be here until the cows come home. Perhaps our Parish’s Adult Religious
Education Program can arrange to cover this subject in a series of classes.
What I want us to reflect on today is the
attitude in our hearts and minds, perhaps even in our prayers and conversations
regarding this issue. Among us Catholics
we have generally three answers to this question of inclusion in God’s favour?
The Catholics of the so-called liberal
persuasion think that it doesn’t matter whether you are Catholic or not. We are all the same; no matter what we do,
God loves us. Don’t worry, be happy,
anything goes. This group forgets the
basic conditions that Isaiah set for both the Jews and Gentiles: faithfulness
to the Lord’s commandments. God’s favour
is not a free-for-all. The invitation to
his banquet is given to all; but it is up to us to respond to that invitation
by doing the needful. Unfortunately,
some wilfully reject the invitation.
At the other end of the spectrum, Catholics
of the so-called conservative persuasion, think that everybody outside the fold
is going straight to hell. They argue
that dialogue with Protestants is not only futile, but is dangerous since it
corrupts the Church with those Protestant ideas. This thinking spares its heavy ammunition for
the Muslims. How often we hear on Talk
Radio, Television and conversations, Catholics and other Christians vilifying
all Muslims, because of the atrocities of some of Muslims! Yes, there are Muslims who use their religion
to do bad things, especially with what is going on the Middle East today. But have some Christians not used the Bible
to justify racial segregation and murder?
For me, this is bad logic and bad reasoning. We cannot leap from the sins of a few to the
conclusion that all are guilty and all are to be excluded from God’s favour.
The third and Catholic attitude towards
outsiders, is that which we have heard in today’s readings and that which is
found consistently in the Church’s teaching.
It is a both . . . and attitude, not the easy “Yes or No” approach. For the Letter to Timothy tells us that God
wishes all to be saved. And that is why
he extends his invitation to everybody, first to the Jews and now to us the
Gentiles. He sent Jesus his Son, to show
us the way, the sure way that leads to salvation. Let us make no mistake about it: the sure way
to salvation is Jesus Christ and his Church.
John Chapter 3: 16 is very clear about that: “For God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone
who believes in him might not perish but might have eternal life.” We must thank the Lord that we have been
fortunate enough to choose the way of Jesus.
As to what happens to those who are not
fortunate to be inside the house like us?
We do not know. That is not for
us to answer; that is for God to answer.
And listening to God’s word, and knowing that the Lord is generous and
merciful, we can have the hope that in ways known only to him, he will let in
others too. This hope is not unfounded,
for as today’s readings tell us, the bottom line, the minimum condition is
faith in God, a faith that can sometimes be even in those outside the
fold. We would also do well to remember
Jesus’ answer to his disciples: “whoever is not against us is for us.”
Conclusion
This hope in the goodness and the salvation
of those outside the fold, should not lessen our faithfulness to the Lord or minimize
our missionary zeal to bring others to the Lord. For the way of Christ and the Church is the
sure, certain and ordinary way; other ways are based only on hope and are
therefore unpredictable, uncertain and extraordinary.
At the same time, we should not exclude the
possibility that the Lord can bring people to himself through these other
ways. What the Lord has to offer us,
eternal life with him, is big enough to be shared among all. Remember the
parable about the workers in the vineyard who came in to work at different
times but received the same reward? Well
in the same way, we who have come to know the Lord earlier, who have been with
him the longest and perhaps been the most faithful, should not be jealous
because the Lord is generous.
I will leave you with Psalm 15, which
begins with these questions: “LORD, who shall be admitted to your tent? Who may
dwell on your holy mountain?” You will
find that the answers to this question do not exclude anyone; it is people who
exclude themselves from God’s invitation by not doing his will. If God does not exclude people, why should
you and I do so?